Marlborough Boys’ College has sparked controversy in the South Island school rugby scene due to its decision to include five Year 14 students in its first XV team. The principal, Jarrod Dunn, explained that these students returned to school because of challenges in finding employment in the region and are participating in academic programs. However, principals from other schools, such as Tim Grocott of Shirley Boys’ High School, argue that having five Year 14s in one team is 'very, very unusual' and undermines the principles of secondary school sport. The issue has reignited debates about the balance between education and competitive sports in schools. The school has also drawn attention for a controversial try during a match against Nelson College, which led to widespread media coverage and public scrutiny. The incident has raised concerns about the impact of televising schoolboy rugby, especially on young players and referees. School Sport NZ is currently reviewing its eligibility rules, with potential changes to exclude Year 14 students from championship-level events.