Government Faces Polling Challenges Amid Pay Equity Controversy

Keywords: New Zealand Government, Pay Equity Reforms, Nicola Willis, Chris Hipkins, Labour Party, Political Polling, Investment Boost, Te Pāti Māori, Adrian Rurawhe, Taxpayers' Union-Curia Poll
Back to News List
Saturday, 07 June 2025
The New Zealand government, led by Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, is navigating a complex political landscape marked by divergent polling results and contentious policy decisions. Recent polls from TVNZ-Verian and RNZ-Reid present conflicting narratives: the former suggests the ruling coalition retains power, while the latter indicates potential loss. This discrepancy underscores the uncertainty surrounding the government's future, particularly in light of its recent budget decisions and ongoing debates over pay equity reforms. The government's 2025 Budget, spearheaded by Finance Minister Nicola Willis, has been a focal point of controversy. The budget includes significant changes to pay equity, which aim to free up $12.8 billion for economic investment through the Investment Boost tax credit. While these measures are intended to stimulate economic growth and reduce the wage gap with Australia, they have been met with strong public backlash. Recent polling by Talbot Mills indicates widespread dissatisfaction, with voters viewing the budget as detrimental to both individuals and the economy. This reaction is reminiscent of the rare negative sentiment seen since the poll began in 1996. Despite the criticism, the government appears to have incurred a relatively minimal political cost for these changes. According to the TVNZ-Verian poll, 39% of voters support the pay equity reforms, while 45% oppose them. Although opposition remains higher, the level of support is notable given the typically contentious nature of such policies. The RNZ-Reid poll shows a wider margin, with only 25.5% supporting the changes, but this figure rises to 38.5% among respondents who claim to understand the reforms. This suggests that while the government may not have won public favor outright, it has managed to avoid severe backlash. The opposition Labour Party, led by Chris Hipkins, is positioning itself as a potential alternative government. Labour has pledged to reverse the government's pay equity changes, with a focus on reallocating funds from the $6.6 billion Investment Boost fund. However, this strategy faces challenges, as the coalition can argue that future wage growth and job creation depend on maintaining the investment incentives provided by the tax credit. This dynamic forces Labour to navigate a delicate political tightrope, balancing its commitment to reversing the budget's changes with the need to avoid alienating voters who might perceive its actions as economically destabilizing. Intra-party dynamics also play a role in shaping the political landscape. Labour's coalition partners, particularly Te Pāti Māori, have been embroiled in a self-absorbed conflict with the Privileges Committee, diverting attention from the pay equity issue. Adrian Rurawhe's recent speech highlighted the dangers of the government's decision to abandon a consensus-based approach to punishing errant MPs, warning of a precedent that could be exploited by future majorities to suppress dissenting voices. His admonition to Te Pāti Māori, invoking the memory of party founder Tariana Turia, emphasized the need for the party to mature and engage more constructively in parliamentary debates. The broader political race remains tight, with Labour performing better than previous first-term oppositions. Polls consistently show Labour ahead of National, a position not seen since the 1990s. This momentum, however, is tempered by challenges in converting wavering voters and addressing the concerns of coalition partners. As the election cycle progresses, both the government and the opposition will need to refine their messaging and strategies to secure public support and navigate the complexities of New Zealand's political landscape. Ultimately, the government's ability to manage the fallout from its budget decisions and maintain public confidence will be crucial in determining its political fortunes. While the current polling suggests a shifting tide against National, the outcome remains uncertain. The coming months will be pivotal in shaping the narrative and determining which party emerges as the next government of New Zealand.