Scott Robertson Praises South Africa's Creative Tactics Amid Rugby Innovation Debate

In a recent development that has sparked widespread discussion in the rugby world, All Blacks coach Scott Robertson has openly supported South Africa’s controversial tactics in their recent match against Italy. The Springboks’ use of innovative and seemingly strategic offside kicks and fake lineouts has raised eyebrows, but Robertson sees it as a natural evolution of the game.

During the Springboks’ 45-0 victory over Italy in Gqeberha, coach Rassie Erasmus employed a unique interpretation of rugby’s laws. The match began with a kick-off where Marnie Libbok was flanked by Marco van Staden and Andre Esterhuizen, both standing in an offside position. Libbok deliberately kicked the ball short, allowing Esterhuizen to gather it and leading to a free kick and scrum for South Africa. This tactic, though controversial, showcased the Springboks’ ability to exploit the rules to their advantage.

Robertson, who has a history of using similar tactics during his time in France, acknowledged the ingenuity behind the move. "We did that in my time in Perpignan," he said. "It’s not new, but it shows the intentions, doesn’t it? That’s the great thing about rugby. It can be innovative, you can use your strengths and surprise people." He emphasized that rugby’s laws, rather than strict rules, allow for such creative approaches.

South Africa’s tactics extended beyond the kick-off. In the first half, they created their own lineout in the middle of open play, leading to a try by Canan Moodie. This move, while effective, has sparked debate over whether it adheres to the laws of the game. Law 9.7 of rugby states that players must not "intentionally infringe on any law of the game," but Robertson sees it as a positive development.

"It’s pretty unique, isn’t it?" Robertson continued. "We’re talking about it, it’s great for our game. People at World Rugby will look at it and play on. Or do you adapt and change? We have laws, not rules. Rules are pretty clear, yes or no. This is one of those ones for interpretation." He believes that innovation is a vital part of the sport’s evolution.

The All Blacks themselves are not strangers to innovation. In their recent 47-13 victory over France in Wellington, the team executed a clever play that misled the French side. From a lineout, No 8 Christian Lio-Willie appeared to peel away from the back of a maul, while Ardie Savea was the actual ball-carrier. The move, devised by assistant coach Bryn Evans, showcased the All Blacks’ willingness to push boundaries.

"The innovation side of it, Bryn has done a really good job. It was a good little play," Robertson said. "Cam bore the fruits of it all as a back, but the forwards will happily claim that one. They walked him in. It was cool." He highlighted the importance of finding new ways to surprise opponents and gain an edge on the field.

As the All Blacks prepare for upcoming matches against South Africa, the focus on innovation and tactical creativity is likely to continue. With both teams aiming to outdo each other, the rugby world is in for an exciting and unpredictable series of matches.